The Freedom of Having Less: OSR Lessons from Brandonsford
It might sound counterintuitive, but the fewer powers, skills, and features your character sheet has, the more freedom you actually have as a player. In crunchier systems like D&D 5e or Pathfinder , when players are faced with a situation, the first thing they do is look at their sheet and "press the buttons" they have available. They look for the magical power that solves the puzzle. They only engage in activities where they have proficiency. And often, the same player ends up doing all the talking just because they have a +8 Charisma. It ends up feeling more like a board game, where each player has their set moves and just repeats them. In contrast, in simpler—and often deadlier—systems, solutions aren't found on the sheet. They're found in player ingenuity and interaction with the environment. You’ll often hear advice in 5e videos about making combat more interesting by encouraging players to interact with the terrain—kick over tables, shove crates, use el...