The Planned Chaos: Creating a Flexible World for Players

 In the last session of my campaign, something curious happened: my players were fascinated. There was betrayal between characters, an unexpected romance, a mystery that left them on edge, and a tactical, exciting combat. In the end, they congratulated me and commented that it was evident how much I had prepared the session. The irony is that I hadn’t prepared anything specific for that session.

What I actually do is "planned chaos: laying the groundwork for an organic story." This concept may seem contradictory, but it’s an approach that allows me to offer complete freedom to my players without losing narrative coherence. I don’t design sessions with a rigid script; instead, I build a solid foundation before the campaign begins, ensuring that I can improvise with ease. This method requires a lot of preparation beforehand, but it significantly lightens the load between sessions, making the experience much more enjoyable for the GM.

How I Prepare Without Preparing

My style as a GM is to prepare extensively before the campaign begins, establishing a world filled with elements I can activate at any moment. Instead of defining every detail, I leave multiple loose ends, creating variety and options for the players. If they take the bait, I develop it on the spot. This allows me to be surprised along with my players and enjoy the chaos without being tied to a predetermined path, as often happens in some modules or sandbox campaigns where everything inevitably leads to the villain’s lair.

Some key elements I define beforehand are:

Factions

Having multiple established factions gives the world depth and interactive possibilities. There’s no need to over-detail them; it’s enough to define:

  • Where they operate.

  • What their objectives are.

  • How they relate to other factions.

  • A leader and a few low-level members accessible to players. This setup allows players to join, oppose, or use these factions for their own purposes without forcing me to improvise everything from scratch.

Rumors

Having a rumor table is very useful for generating interest. These rumors can serve as narrative hooks, such as:

  • "A comet crashed to the north."

  • "Mysterious fires are appearing in the nearby forest."

  • "A wizard is conducting experiments two days' travel away." These events don’t need to be fully fleshed out from the start. The key is to keep them close enough so that players can reach them in a single session, giving me time to expand them during the week if they choose to investigate.

NPCs

In my current campaign, which is a megadungeon, I prepared a few recurring adventuring groups and key NPCs in the city. For example, a group called "Johnny and his Fingers" encountered the players. When designing them, I accidentally made five members instead of six, which would be expected given Johnny + 5 Fingers. When the players asked about the missing "finger," I improvised by saying it was a taboo topic. Now they’re intrigued and want to uncover the story behind it—something that emerged completely spontaneously.

For the city, I created three NPCs per district with:

  • A physical and personality description.

  • A main activity.

  • A desire or goal.

  • A secret. The desires and secrets are usually intertwined with other NPCs, allowing players to connect the dots and inspire new ideas during the session. Additionally, I always recommend including a mysterious and seductive NPC. These characters naturally attract players and can serve as allies or betrayers—both options leading to interesting outcomes.

Outside Entities

Unlike factions, these are mysterious forces that destabilize the balance of the world. They can act as catalysts for conflicts between factions or as events that players decide to explore further. Their enigmatic nature allows me to reveal information gradually and develop them as the campaign progresses.

Encounter Tables That Aren’t Just Enemies

When designing random encounter tables, only 30% of encounters are enemies. The rest include strange events, peculiar NPCs, or minor mysteries that players can interpret as they wish. Examples:

  • A violet feather on the ground.

  • A golden doll that speaks Goblin.

  • A jade ring with an unknown symbol. Players always assume these elements have a purpose and develop their own theories. This allows me to build upon their creativity instead of imposing a single predetermined truth.

Tracking and Adapting

Keeping notes on player interests and the connections they make in the story is essential for adjusting elements on the fly. I let the pieces fall into place naturally, reshaping them based on their actions and decisions.

Preparation Time

I spend a few weeks or even a month before the campaign begins preparing this foundation. Then, with just an hour before each session, I’m ready to run everything smoothly. This method lets me play fluidly, react to players, and be surprised in every session without needing a detailed script.


This method not only allows me to offer a rich world full of options but also frees me as a GM. I don’t have to constantly prepare highly detailed sessions or worry about forcing a specific plot. Instead, I let the story unfold organically through player interactions with the world. It’s an approach that fosters creativity for both me and my players, keeping excitement and surprise alive in every session.

This is planned chaos: laying the groundwork for an organic story, where improvisation isn’t a leap into the unknown but the natural consequence of intelligent preparation.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Dungeon's Heart: City Building Tips

Image
One of the challenges in dungeon-delving RPG campaigns is figuring out what to do with all the gold. Players often amass large sums of money without knowing how to spend it. The usual recommendations are upgrading equipment or managing a stronghold , but these are often vague suggestions without clear mechanics to support them. One aspect I appreciate about His Majesty the Worm , the game I'm currently running, is its structured approach to the economy. When adventurers return to the surface, the City Phase begins, requiring them to pay taxes on their expedition's earnings, choose their level of comfort for lodging, and perform a City Action . These special actions allow gold to be spent in interesting ways with clear mechanics: commissioning a rare artifact (with a cost based on the number of words in its description), going on a spree to gain experience, hiring training services, building a tavern, and more. These actions are standard, but the rulebook encourages adding dist...
Read more

Building a Modular Megadungeon: Design, Challenges, and First Impressions

Image
 The dungeon in my campaign is created by a Dream Worm , so I thought it would be a great opportunity to experiment with a modular dungeon . The idea is that every time the players leave, the dungeon reconfigures itself based on their dreams and fears. Additionally, random events can trigger shifts in the module layout during exploration. Designing the Modules To simplify the process, I decided to make square modules . I then had to determine how many rooms each module should have and how many modules would make up each floor. Module and Room Count I settled on 12 modules per floor to ensure a good variety of layouts without making the combinations too predictable. Each module contains between 8 and 15 rooms . Initially, I considered 30 rooms per module , but that would result in 300 rooms per floor , making exploration too slow. I want my players to move through multiple levels, so I reduced the number. For reference, adventures like The Hole in the Oak and Against the Cult of...
Read more